Lawyers Debate Merits of Boehner Lawsuit

By Andrew Rafferty

 

Constitutional lawyers tussled over the merits of a planned Republican-led lawsuit against President Barack Obama on Wednesday, as Democrats continued to dismiss the suit as frivolous and a political stunt.

 

Attorneys in support of the suit told the House Rules Committee that Obama has overstepped his Constitutional authority by unilaterally modifying the implementation of the Affordable Care Act. It is a recent illustration of the long-term shift of power from Congress to the executive branch, they said.

 

“At some point this body has to take a stand and try to realign these branches,” said George Washington University law professor Jonathan Turley. “If it doesn’t I think this system is going to change in a very significant, and in my view, dangerous way.”

 

Democratic witnesses warned that the proposed litigation would give too much power to the courts and open the door to almost limitless possibilities for different bodies of government to sue each other.

 

“It would create a mess on a scale that is hard for any of us to even think about,” said Simon Lazarus, an attorney of the Constitutional Accountability Center.

 

Obama has called the suit a “political stunt” and said executive actions were necessary because Republicans have been unwilling to work with him.

More from

Rule of Law
September 24, 2024

RELEASE: Senate Judiciary Committee Rightly Focuses on the Harms of Trump v. United States and Grapples with Damage Mitigation

WASHINGTON, DC – As the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, ‘When the President Does It, that...
By: Praveen Fernandes
Rule of Law
September 23, 2024

Sign On Letter: 75 Organizations Call to Overturn Supreme Court Presidential Immunity Ruling

September 23, 2024 The Honorable Richard Durbin, Chairman Ranking Member Lindsay Graham Honorable Members, Committee...
Voting Rights and Democracy
September 20, 2024

“Will the Supreme Court Revive the Dangerous Fringe Election Theory It Just Rejected?”

Election Law Blog
Anna Jessurun in Slate: As several scholars predicted, ISLT proponents have now seized on the language in Moore to...
Voting Rights and Democracy
September 19, 2024

Will the Supreme Court Revive the Dangerous Fringe Election Theory It Just Rejected?

Slate
From troubling election denialism to rampant misinformation about voter fraud, there are already multiple respects...
By: Anna Jessurun
Rule of Law
September 12, 2024

September 2024 Newsletter: CAC Fights in the Lower Courts to Support Voting Rights and the Legality of Progressive Policies

Immigration and Citizenship
September 10, 2024

Trump, Vance y estos congresistas latinos quieren acabar con la ciudadanía por nacimiento. ¿Pueden hacerlo?

Telemundo
Quien nace en territorio estadounidense es considerado ciudadano por la Constitución desde hace 156 años....