Rule of Law

Release: Supreme Court Right To Take Up CFPB Funding Issue and Should Reverse the Fifth Circuit’s Decision That Is at Odds with Constitutional Text and History

WASHINGTON, DC – On news that the Supreme Court has agreed to hear Community Financial Services Association of America v. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the challenge to the constitutionality of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s (CFPB’s) funding structure, CAC Chief Counsel Brianne Gorod said:

The Supreme Court was right today to agree to review the Fifth Circuit’s decision holding the CFPB’s funding structure unconstitutional.  That decision is both profoundly wrong and incredibly dangerous, and the Supreme Court should reverse it.

According to the Fifth Circuit, the CFPB’s funding structure is unconstitutional because the CFPB does not rely on annual appropriations from Congress.  Notably, however, the requirement the Fifth Circuit would impose can be found nowhere in the text of the Constitution, and it is contrary to established practice going back to the beginning of the nation.

CAC Senior Appellate Counsel Brian Frazelle continued:

Congress has long exercised the flexibility the Constitution gives it to fund agencies through means other than appropriations from the Treasury.  For example, as early as the 1790s, Congress authorized the post office to operate using funds from postage fees, rather than withdrawals from the Treasury.  Moreover, the CFPB is hardly unique among modern-day federal agencies in being funded outside the annual appropriations process.

Indeed, that is why the Fifth Circuit’s decision threatens not only the important work that the CFPB does on behalf of America’s consumers, but also could imperil the funding of many other federal agencies, including the Federal Reserve.

The Supreme Court should reverse the Fifth Circuit’s lawless decision and hold, as it has held before, that the Constitution’s Appropriations Clause simply requires that the funding of federal agencies be authorized by Congress, as it plainly was here.

##

Resources:

Brianne J. Gorod, Brian R. Frazelle, & Alex Rowell, As Wrong as It is Dangerous: The Fifth Circuit’s Decision Holding the CFPB Funding Structure Unconstitutional: https://www.theusconstitution.org/blog/blog-as-wrong-as-it-is-dangerous-the-fifth-circuits-decision-holding-the-cfpb-funding-structure-unconstitutional/

Brian Frazelle, The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s funding is constitutional: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/02/20/cfpb-funding-fees-constitutional/

##

Constitutional Accountability Center is a nonpartisan think tank and public interest law firm dedicated to fulfilling the progressive promise of the Constitution’s text, history, and values. Visit CAC’s website at www.theusconstitution.org.

###

More from Rule of Law

Rule of Law
April 25, 2025

When does President Donald Trump’s defiance of courts in deportation case cross the line into a constitutional crisis?

Cronkite News
WASHINGTON – Presidents of both parties have pushed the limits of their authority throughout history....
Rule of Law
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia

American Foreign Service Association v. Trump

In American Foreign Service Association v. Trump, the United States District Court for the District of Columbia is considering whether the Trump Administration’s efforts to unilaterally dismantle USAID are constitutional and comply with federal law.
Rule of Law
April 14, 2025

Congressional Democrats Fight Back Against Trump’s Attacks on the FTC and Independent Agencies

Cory Booker Senate
Today, Senate and House Democrats filed an amicus brief opposing President Donald Trump’s unlawful attempt...
Rule of Law
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia

Slaughter v. Trump

In Slaughter v. Trump, the United States District Court for the District of Columbia is considering whether Trump’s attempted firing of Commissioners Rebecca Slaughter and Alvaro Bedoya from the Federal Trade Commission was illegal.
Rule of Law
April 29, 2025

Is the US headed for a constitutional crisis?

Deutsche Welle
US President Donald Trump is issuing executive orders on a daily basis. So far, he’s...
Rule of Law
April 10, 2025

April 2025 Newsletter: Supporting New Scholarship for the Next Generation

Supporting New Scholarship for the Next Generation On March 20 and 21, CAC was thrilled...