Rule of Law

What Is The Emoluments Clause? Appellate Court Throws Out Suit Against Trump


  • The emoluments clause prohibits federal officials, including the president, from accepting payments from foreign governments
  • Trump’s attorneys say that should not apply to profits from ongoing businesses
  • At least 22 foreign governments reportedly have spent money at Trump properties

An appellate court ruled Friday Democratic lawmakers cannot sue President Trump for illegally profiting from his private businesses while in office.

The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the lawmakers did not have the standing to sue.

The suit was filed based on the Constitution’s emoluments clause, which prohibits federal officials from receiving payments or gifts that could result in undue foreign influence. It requires consent from Congress before anything benefits can be received from foreign states.

Trump declined to divest himself from his business empire while in office – the first president not to do so in U.S. history – and his properties regularly receive payments from foreign governments for such things as stays at his hotels. Some 200 members of Congress filed suit to compel Trump to comply with the Constitution in June 2017, about six months after Trump took office.

But the appellate court dismissed the case.

“The members can, and likely will, continue to use their weighty voices to make their case to the American people, their colleagues in the Congress and the president himself, all of whom are free to engage that argument as they see fit,” the judges wrote in a 12-page opinion. “But we will not—indeed we cannot—participate in this debate.”

Justice Department attorneys argued on Trump’s behalf that the clause should be interpreted narrowly and refer only to payments for official action. The appellate court ruled that argument moot.

The decision overturns a lower court order that granted the lawmakers standing.

“Trump’s failure to comply with the Constitution matters. The founders included the foreign emoluments clause in the Constitution because they recognized that payments and gifts to U.S. officials by foreign governments could compromise the judgment of those officials and undermine their loyalty to the United States, thereby harming the American people,” the Constitutional Accountability Center said.

An NBC News review in July indicated at least 22 foreign governments spent money at Trump properties but the total dollar value was unavailable because the Trump Organization, which is privately held, does not open its books. Trump promised to donate any profits from foreign entities to the Treasury. In 2017 and 2018 he sent $343,000 but did not provide the underlying numbers.


More from Rule of Law

Rule of Law
February 7, 2020

Court tosses lawmaker lawsuit against Trump over emoluments

CQ/Roll Call
A federal appeals court in Washington on Friday dismissed a lawsuit brought by more than...
By: Elizabeth B. Wydra, By Todd Ruger
Rule of Law
February 13, 2020

Advocates In Conn. Sue ICE, Claiming Agency’s Acting-Director Is Serving Illegally

A lawsuit filed Thursday in Connecticut's U.S. District Court alleges the Trump administration's acting director of U.S....
By: Brianne J. Gorod, By Shannon Dooling
Rule of Law
U.S. District Court for the District of Connecticut

ASISTA Immigration Assistance v. Albence

Challenging a Trump Administration change in immigration policy that harms crime victims and law enforcement efforts, because the official who issued the new policy is serving unlawfully as the Acting Director of U.S. Immigration and...
Rule of Law
February 7, 2020

Appeals court rules Democrats can’t sue Trump over emoluments claims

The Hill
“The Framers included the Foreign Emoluments Clause in the Constitution as the Constitution’s chief bulwark...
By: Elizabeth B. Wydra, By Harper Neidig
Rule of Law
February 7, 2020

Appeals court determines Blumenthal, other Democrats lack standing to sue Trump

Hartford Courant
“The Court of Appeals did not in any way approve of President Trump’s repeated and...
By: Elizabeth B. Wydra, By Ana Radelat
Rule of Law
February 7, 2020

Federal appeals court tosses Democrats’ emoluments clause lawsuit against Trump

New York Post
A federal appeals court on Friday tossed a lawsuit brought by Democratic lawmakers alleging that...
By: Elizabeth B. Wydra, By Bob Fredericks