ISSUE BRIEF (ACS): The Roberts Court, the Shadow Docket, and the Unraveling of Voting Rights Remedies

Published originally by the American Constitution Society

Year in and year out, the Supreme Court’s major rulings in argued cases generate outsized attention. But the Supreme Court’s merits docket is just half the story. This past year, some of the most important decisions came in unsigned, and sometimes unexplained, orders related to whether to stay a lower court’s ruling; this part of the Court’s docket has been called the “shadow docket” because it frequently goes unnoticed.

Summary

Through these cursory orders, the Roberts Court has been rewriting the rules of our democracy to prevent courts from vindicating the right to vote in an election year. Even as our nation is battling a deadly pandemic that has made exercising the right to vote more difficult, the Roberts Court is closing the courthouse doors on citizens seeking to vindicate the right to vote when it matters most.

More from Voting Rights and Democracy

Voting Rights and Democracy
Wisconsin Supreme Court

Wisconsin Business Leaders for Democracy v. Wisconsin Elections Commission

In Wisconsin Business Leaders for Democracy v. Wisconsin Elections Commission, the Wisconsin Supreme Court is considering the legality of Wisconsin’s congressional redistricting map.
Voting Rights and Democracy
July 8, 2026

“Ruling Away From America’s Second Founding” on the Election Law Blog

Election Law Blog
David Gans’s Slate article on the Roberts Court was featured on Election Law Blog. Read more.
Voting Rights and Democracy
June 30, 2026

CAC Release: Roberts Court Strikes Down Yet Another Campaign Finance Law, Turns Blind Eye to Corruption

WASHINGTON, DC – Following today’s decision at the Supreme Court in National Republican Senatorial Committee...
By: Miriam Becker-Cohen, David H. Gans
Voting Rights and Democracy
June 29, 2026

CAC Release: Supreme Court Rebukes Fifth Circuit, Affirms State Authority to Permit Post-Election Receipt of Mail Ballots

WASHINGTON, DC – Following today’s decision at the Supreme Court in Watson v. Republican National...
By: David H. Gans, Simon Chin
Voting Rights and Democracy
June 21, 2026

Guns, Weed, and the Forgotten Framers

Slate
CAC's David H. Gans discussed his forthcoming paper in the Stanford Law Review on the Black Conventions...
Voting Rights and Democracy
June 3, 2026

How Congress Can Pass a New Voting Rights Act Despite the Supreme Court

Slate
Director of the Human Rights, Civil Rights & Citizenship David H. Gans wrote an article in...
By: David H. Gans