Voting Rights and Democracy

OP-ED: The Census Case Will Define the Roberts Court

More than two centuries ago, the Constitution’s Framers decided the United States would be the first nation to make a count of all persons an important method of ensuring a democracy. Sadly, this history was barely acknowledged at Tuesday’s oral argument in Department of Commerce v. New Yorkwhich involves a challenge to Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross’ decision to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census, a change that would skew the headcount mandated by our foundational charter. On Tuesday, the Constitution was missing in action.

The court’s conservative justices, echoing last term’s 5–4 decision upholding President Donald Trump’s travel ban, suggested in their questioning that they should defer to the secretary’s decision to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census, notwithstanding Ross’ blatant manipulation of the administrative process. Solicitor General Noel Francisco argued that this was a policy judgment based on weighing costs and benefits, which should be left to the secretary. “You’re always trading off information and accuracy,” Francisco insisted. Courts, the solicitor general seemed to argue, have no business interfering.

More from Voting Rights and Democracy

Voting Rights and Democracy
April 23, 2019

Supreme Court conservatives appear ready to OK Trump’s census citizenship question

Los Angeles Times
The Supreme Court’s conservative justices appeared ready on Tuesday to uphold the Trump administration’s plan...
Voting Rights and Democracy
April 23, 2019

RELEASE: Court’s Conservatives Send Troubling Signals On Integrity Of 2020 Census

“The integrity of the 2020 Census is clearly at issue in this case, but nothing...
By: Brianne J. Gorod, David H. Gans, Elizabeth B. Wydra
Voting Rights and Democracy
April 13, 2019

Inside Trump administration’s mysterious plan to secure a 2020 census citizenship question

USA Today
Wilbur Ross had just started running the Department of Commerce, but he was growing impatient...
Voting Rights and Democracy
April 11, 2019

Annotated Guide to the Amicus Briefs in the Supreme Court’s Citizenship Question Cases

Brennan Center for Justice
As the Supreme Court takes up challenges to the 2020 Census citizenship question, almost 50...
Voting Rights and Democracy
April 12, 2019

Lincoln Ideas Forum: Voting Rights at Lincoln’s Cottage

Host: Grateful American™ Foundation
Join us as we bring together experts, scholars, and the public in an exploration of...
Participants: Brianne J. Gorod, Lillian Cunningham (Moderator), Robert Tsai, Elaine Weiss, Jason Torchinsky
Voting Rights and Democracy
April 1, 2019

Will the Supreme Court Follow the Law and Save the Census?

The Census is the cornerstone of our democracy.  To ensure equal representation for all, the...
By: David H. Gans