Civil and Human Rights

American Council of Learned Societies v. McDonald

In American Council of Learned Societies v. McDonald, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit is considering whether DOGE’s targeted terminations of federal humanities grants that studied race, gender, and other protected traits violated the Fifth Amendment right to equal protection.

Case Summary

The National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH) is a federal agency that awards competitive grants to fund scholarly humanistic work. This case concerns the April 2025 revocation of more than 1,400 previously awarded NEH grants worth over $100,000,000. The grants were terminated by staffers from the federal Department of Government Efficiency Service (DOGE) because they involved projects touching on race, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sex, and sexual orientation. DOGE staffers used keyword searches to identify grant descriptions that included, among other terms, “BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, People of Color),” “Minorities,” “Native,” “Tribal,” “Indigenous,” “Immigrant,” “LGBTQ,” “Homosexual,” and “Gay.”  There were no similar searches for “white,” “Caucasian,” or “heterosexual.” DOGE staffers also used ChatGPT to identify “grants involving DEI,” which classified grants as “DEI” because they involved specific races, ethnicities, religions, or genders.

The plaintiffs, leading scholarly organizations in the humanities, challenged the grant terminations in a New York district court. They argued that, among other claims, the grant terminations violated the Fifth Amendment right to equal protection. The district court agreed. The Trump administration appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, and CAC filed an amicus brief in November 2026 explaining that the cuts to the grants violated the Fifth Amendment.

First, the text and history of the Fourteenth Amendment show the breadth of the Fifth Amendment’s parallel guarantee of equal protection. As courts have long recognized, the Fifth Amendment’s equal-protection component is coextensive with the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause, such that the history of the latter is directly probative in considering the scope of the former. The Framers of the Fourteenth Amendment were deeply concerned about violence and discrimination targeting Black communities during Reconstruction, as well as the documented violence and discrimination faced by white allies targeted based on their association with Black Americans. In line with this history, the Supreme Court has never limited equal-protection liability to discrimination based on one’s own constitutionally protected traits, recognizing constitutional violations when people are targeted for adverse treatment based on the race of their spouse or companion.

Second, the Constitution’s equal-protection guarantee bars the government from using protected traits like race to impose negative consequences. Here, DOGE identified NEH grants by searching their descriptions for references to race, religion, ethnicity, national origin, sex, and sexual orientation and then terminated them. Longstanding equal-protection doctrine forbids this sort of government action. Although the government attempts to frame its classification of these grants as making viewpoint-based distinctions, the Supreme Court—more than half a century ago—identified a similar sorting scheme as an “explicitly racial classification” subject to heightened constitutional scrutiny. In that case, the Court held that a city amendment that imposed extra procedural hurdles for laws that dealt with race and other protected traits (and only those laws) violated the Equal Protection Clause. The grant terminations here follow exactly that pattern, and therefore violate the Fifth Amendment right to equal protection.

DOGE’s grant terminations cannot survive any level of scrutiny, and the Second Circuit should hold that they were unconstitutional.

Case Timeline

More from Civil and Human Rights

Civil and Human Rights
November 9, 2026

CAC Release: Supreme Court Precedent and Constitutional History Both Support Access to Court When Prison Staff Violate the Eighth Amendment

WASHINGTON, DC – Following oral argument at the Supreme Court this morning in Nielsen v....
By: Joshua Blecher-Cohen, David H. Gans
Civil and Human Rights
November 3, 2026

Inside the Supreme Court case that could decide Title IX employee protections

Higher Ed Dive
CAC’s Miriam Becker-Cohen spoke to Higher Ed Dive about Crowther v. Board of Regents of the...
Civil and Human Rights
November 3, 2026

CAC Release: St. Mary Catholic Parish’s Request to Discriminate Runs Afoul of Constitutional Text and History, As Well As Supreme Court Precedent

WASHINGTON, DC – Following oral argument at the Supreme Court this morning in St. Mary...
By: Joshua Blecher-Cohen, David H. Gans, Praveen Fernandes
Civil and Human Rights
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit

Williams v. Huner

In Williams v. Huner, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit is considering whether a Pennsylvania prison’s failure to provide a prisoner with rigid neck and wrist braces and effective pain medication violated...
Civil and Human Rights
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit

Womble v. Patel

In Womble v. Patel, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit is considering whether a North Carolina prison’s failure to provide a prisoner with a hearing-aid battery violated the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Civil and Human Rights
U.S. Supreme Court

St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy

In St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, the Supreme Court is considering whether the Free Exercise Clause requires Colorado to allow religious preschool providers to join its state-funded universal preschool program even though they refuse...