Corporate Accountability

The Basic Difference Between Campaign Contributions and Expenditures: A Reply to Bob Bauer

Bob Bauer tries, once again, to complicate the campaign contribution-expenditure distinction, suggesting that our brief on behalf of Professor Lawrence Lessig missed the key issue in McCutcheon v. FEC, next Term’s upcoming sequel to Citizens United.   While there may be cases in which the line between the two forms of regulation is blurred (such as instances in which a candidate donates money to his or her own campaign), McCutcheon isn’t one of them.  The federal law aggregate contribution limits at issue in McCutcheon permit an individual to make a total of $123,200 in campaign contributions per election cycle ($48,600 to candidates and $74,600 to parties and non-party political committees).  If this sounds and looks like a contribution limit, that’s because it is one.  Shaun McCutcheon is free to spend as much as he likes on campaign ads for as many candidates or political parties as he likes, but he may not make an unlimited amount of political contributions.  The very reason for these limits – as well as the longstanding distinction between expenditures and contributions – is that a system of unlimited financial contributions can breed a corrupting dependence on high dollar donors. 

The best that Bauer can muster is that the limits at issue in McCutcheon restrict the total amount an individual may spend on campaign contributions.  This is silly word play and it does not make his case for the simple reason that the contribution limits in no way prevent McCutcheon from spending money on independent efforts to elect the candidates of his choice. The Supreme Court was not fooled by this argument in Buckley v. Valeo, when it upheld an earlier version of the aggregate limits challenged by McCutcheon, describing them as “no more than a corollary of the basic individual contribution limitation.”  Neither should the Roberts Court be in McCutcheon. 

Bauer’s unrelenting focus on the expenditure-contribution distinction not only misses the point, but it obscures our brief’s powerful originalist case, which demonstrates that Citizens United’s cramped understanding of corruption has no basis in the Constitution and that, under the Framers’ conception of corruption, the aggregate limits should be upheld.  Bauer is correct in noting that our brief does not spend much time parsing the nuances of the limits on candidates, parties, and other political committees.  We left that job to the parties and other amici, in part because the history shows that the Court should err (if at all) on the side of upholding a statute designed to combat the very sort of improper dependence on outside forces that the Framers wrote the Constitution to check.  If the Justices follow the Constitution’s text and history, they will uphold these limits and begin to correct the grievous errors of Citizens United.

More from Corporate Accountability

Corporate Accountability
October 2, 2026

Corporations Fared Even Better Than President Trump in the Supreme Court’s Prior Term, and the Upcoming Term Provides More Opportunities for Corporate Wins

WASHINGTON, DC – With the start of the new Supreme Court term on Monday, the...
By: Brian R. Frazelle
Corporate Accountability
October 2, 2026

Corporations Outdo Even President Trump in the Most Recent Supreme Court Term (2025–2026 Term)

After a Supreme Court term that gave corporations everything they wanted in the most important...
By: Brian R. Frazelle
Corporate Accountability
November 13, 2026

CAC Release: Corporations Fare Even Better Than President Trump in the Supreme Court, Constitutional Accountability Center Finds

WASHINGTON, DC – The Supreme Court has just released its final decisions in cases argued...
By: Brian R. Frazelle
Corporate Accountability
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia

AbbVie v. Department of Health and Human Services

In AbbVie v. Department of Health and Human Services, the United States District Court for the District of Columbia considered whether the Inflation Reduction Act’s Medicare drug price negotiation program is an unconstitutional taking of...
Corporate Accountability
June 5, 2026

US Supreme Court backs federal regulators in wins for FCC and SEC

Reuters
CAC Chief Counsel Brianne Gorod was quoted in Reuters discussing recent Supreme Court wins for...
Corporate Accountability
June 4, 2026

CAC Release: Supreme Court Recognizes the Importance of History in Validating FCC Enforcement Process

WASHINGTON, DC – Following today’s decision at the Supreme Court in Federal Communications Commission v....
By: Smita Ghosh, Joshua Blecher-Cohen