Rule of Law

Ideologically Diverse Moot Court Panel Votes 8-1 that ACA Individual Mandate is Constitutional

As the Supreme Court gears up to hear oral arguments in the Affordable Care Act cases next week, the Peter Jennings Project for Journalists and the Constitution tested the central issue of the Act at its Sixth Annual Moot Court Program on March 20.  During the simulated court proceedings, a panel of distinguished law professors, noted legal thinkers, and current and former federal judges — including four Bush (41 and 43) appointees and CAC Board member and former DC Circuit Judge Patricia Wald  — heard oral arguments on the constitutionality of the minimum coverage provision in the ACA and voted 8-1 that the ACA’s mandate that Americans obtain insurance coverage or face a tax penalty is within Congress’s constitutional power to regulate interstate commerce.   

You can watch the webcast of this terrific moot court program below:

CAC will attend the actual oral arguments at the Supreme Court next week, so be sure to read CAC’s brief, filed on behalf of more than 500 state legislators from all 50 states in support of the constitutionality of the minimum coverage provision here, and stay tuned to Text & History as developments in these critical cases unfold. 

More from Rule of Law

Rule of Law
May 20, 2026

Over 440 Civil Rights, Faith, and Labor Organizations Call Department of Justice Indictment of Southern Poverty Law Center a “Naked Attempt to Weaponize the the Criminal Justice System to Silence Speech”

The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights
CAC joined over 440 civil rights, faith, and labor organizations calling the Department of Justice...
Rule of Law
May 17, 2026

New lawsuit filed by a group of Miami residents seeks to block “outrageous” Trump Presidential Library

CBS News
Sistrunk Seeds v. Trump, the lawsuit brought by the Constitutional Accountability Center and the law...
Rule of Law
May 15, 2026

DeSantis dismisses validity of new Trump library lawsuit during Miami appearance

Miami Herald
Sistrunk Seeds v. Trump, the lawsuit brought by the Constitutional Accountability Center and the law...
Rule of Law
May 17, 2026

Lawsuit challenges proposed Trump Presidential Library site in downtown Miami

Local 10 News
Sistrunk Seeds v. Trump, the lawsuit brought by the Constitutional Accountability Center and the law...
Rule of Law
May 14, 2026

No Books, Two Golden Statues: Trump’s $130 Million Miami ‘Presidential Library’ Skyscraper Hit With Lawsuit

International Business Times
Sistrunk Seeds v. Trump, the lawsuit brought by the Constitutional Accountability Center and the law...
Rule of Law
May 14, 2026

Trump Library hit with another lawsuit as Florida GOP makes more changes to the state

PantherNOW
Sistrunk Seeds v. Trump, the lawsuit brought by the Constitutional Accountability Center and the law...