Text and History Narratives

The Keystone of the Arch: The Text and History of Article III and the Constitution’s Promise of Access to Courts

When the Constitution was framed, the promise of access to the federal courts was at the heart of a new system of government accountable to the people.

Summary

When the Constitution was framed, the promise of access to the federal courts was at the heart of a new system of government accountable to the people. As John Marshall— soon to become our Nation’s greatest Chief Justice—observed, “[t]o what quarter will you look for protection from an infringement on the Constitution, if you will not give the power to the judiciary? There is no other body that can afford such a protection.” The federal judiciary, with the Supreme Court at its head, would be the “keystone of the arch,” establishing a binding rule of law for the nation. In Article III, the Framers created the federal judiciary as a co-equal branch of government vested with the power of expounding and enforcing the laws in cases and controversies. Today, the Framers’ constitutional vision is in shambles. Over the last several decades, conservative Justices on the Supreme Court have emasculated this fundamental constitutional principle, filling the United States Reports with arcane and impenetrable doctrines that do violence to the rule-of-law values at the Constitution’s core. Armed with this history, progressives have a chance to restore basic constitutional first principles that give Americans their day in court to redress legal wrongs and prevent abuse of power by the government. The story laid out in this Narrative shows why this is what the Constitution’s text and history requires.

CAC released The Keystone of the Arch at an event hosted at Georgetown Law School’s Supreme Court Institute on November 3, 2016.

More from Civil and Human Rights

Civil and Human Rights
September 12, 2018

It’s Time to Close a Loophole in the Constitution’s Double Jeopardy Rule

ACLU
The Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment states that no one can be tried...
Civil and Human Rights
September 16, 2018

Understanding the three-fifths compromise

San Antonio Express-News
Constitution Day is today. The U.S. Constitution is a document that evolves with the times....
Civil and Human Rights
August 22, 2018

Toward a More Perfect Union: The LGBTQ Community and the Constitution

Host: American Constitution Society and Human Rights Campaign
Join ACS and HRC for an afternoon symposium addressing the relationship between the LGBTQ community,...
Participants: Praveen Fernandes, Katie Eyer, Caroline Fredrickson, Nancy J. Knauer, Sharon McGowan, Shannon Minter, Steve Sanders, Paul Smith, Ria Tabacco Mar, Harper Jean Tobin, Sarah Warbelow, JoDee Winterhof
Civil and Human Rights
September 21, 2018

The 14th Amendment at 150 Symposium

Ratified 150 years ago, the 14th Amendment has been called America’s “Second Founding.” The Bill...
Participants: Brianne J. Gorod, Hon. Judge Elizabeth L. Branch, Hon. Judge Douglas H. Ginsburg, Hon. Judge David R. Stras, Hon. Judge Timothy M. Tymkovich, Hon. Dale Wainwright, Hon. Judge Don R. Willett, Hon. Justice Patrick Wyrick, Dana Berliner, Evan D. Bernick, David Bernstein, Josh Blackman, Robert J. Cottrol, Hon. Dominic Draye, Katie Eyer, Aderson B. Francois, Christopher Green, Martha Jones, Kurt Lash, Hon. Elbert Lin, Gerard N. Magliocca, John Malcolm, Timothy Sandefur, Anthony Sanders, Ilya Shapiro, Samuel Spital, Rebecca E. Zietlow
Civil and Human Rights
August 9, 2018

Crisis In The Courts: The Future of LGBT Equality and the Federal Judiciary

Host: National LGBT Bar Association
Civil and Human Rights
July 19, 2018

Michael Anton’s Op-Ed on Ending Birthright Citizenship Is Racist, Ahistorical Gobbledygook

Slate
Should Donald Trump issue an executive order purporting to strip millions of children of immigrants...