Civil and Human Rights

CAC Release: Roberts Court’s Conservative Supermajority Hollows Out Equal Protection Guarantee

WASHINGTON, DC – Following today’s decision at the Supreme Court in Little v. Hecox and West Virginia v. B.P.J., cases in which the Court considered whether laws in Idaho and West Virginia that prohibit all transgender women and girls from joining women’s and girls’ sports teams are constitutional, Constitutional Accountability Center Director of the Human Rights, Civil Rights, and Citizenship Program David Gans issued the following reaction:

The Fourteenth Amendment’s universal promise of equality was designed to end prejudicial exclusions of marginalized persons, ensuring equal citizenship stature for all.  Today, the Roberts Court’s conservative supermajority hollows out this bedrock promise, upholding discriminatory laws that exclude transgender women and girls from participation in sport teams and clubs without the hard look the Constitution requires.  Rather than follow the Supreme Court’s precedents, the majority substitutes a watered-down form of judicial scrutiny, deferring to the state and permitting it to exclude from participation in sports all transgender women and girls, even those who possess no biological advantage.

Constitutional Accountability Center Appellate Counsel Joshua Blecher-Cohen continued:

The Fourteenth Amendment provides that no state shall “deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” As the CAC amicus brief explained, the history of the Amendment underscores its breadth and application to “any person.” In upholding laws in West Virginia and Idaho that exclude transgender women and girls like B.P.J. and Lindsay Hecox from participating in school sports, the Court today denies them that guarantee of equal protection.

Constitutional Accountability Center Vice President Praveen Fernandes also noted:

The Roberts Court’s conservative supermajority made unnecessary factual findings that have not been properly litigated in the lower courts. As Justice Sotomayor’s dissent points out, this was flatly wrong, and it is an error that comes with real harms for transgender women and girls.

More from Civil and Human Rights

Civil and Human Rights
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

American Council of Learned Societies v. McDonald

In American Council of Learned Societies v. McDonald, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit is considering whether DOGE’s targeted terminations of federal humanities grants that studied race, gender, and other protected traits...
Civil and Human Rights
November 9, 2026

CAC Release: Supreme Court Precedent and Constitutional History Both Support Access to Court When Prison Staff Violate the Eighth Amendment

WASHINGTON, DC – Following oral argument at the Supreme Court this morning in Nielsen v....
By: Joshua Blecher-Cohen, David H. Gans
Civil and Human Rights
November 3, 2026

Inside the Supreme Court case that could decide Title IX employee protections

Higher Ed Dive
CAC’s Miriam Becker-Cohen spoke to Higher Ed Dive about Crowther v. Board of Regents of the...
Civil and Human Rights
November 3, 2026

CAC Release: St. Mary Catholic Parish’s Request to Discriminate Runs Afoul of Constitutional Text and History, As Well As Supreme Court Precedent

WASHINGTON, DC – Following oral argument at the Supreme Court this morning in St. Mary...
By: Joshua Blecher-Cohen, David H. Gans, Praveen Fernandes
Civil and Human Rights
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit

Williams v. Huner

In Williams v. Huner, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit is considering whether a Pennsylvania prison’s failure to provide a prisoner with rigid neck and wrist braces and effective pain medication violated...
Civil and Human Rights
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit

Womble v. Patel

In Womble v. Patel, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit is considering whether a North Carolina prison’s failure to provide a prisoner with a hearing-aid battery violated the Americans with Disabilities Act.